Tanked vs Tankless Water Heaters: How to Choose

By Aztil – July 3, 2024

Your choice of water heaters will shape the comfort and functionality of your home. Traditional tanked water heaters maintain a reservoir of hot water but can be drained. Tankless water heaters heat water on demand. but they have a limited flow rate. Each has both advantages and disadvantages that are worthy of consideration. Which is better for your home? Understanding the differences can help you choose the right water heating system for your home and lifestyle.

Join us in a detailed comparison of tanked vs tankless water heaters and how to choose between them.

Tanked Water Heaters

Tanked water heaters store water in a large metal tank. These tanks range from 20 to 80 gallons. The water is then heated using heating elements at the bottom of the tank, up to the set temperature of the unit. This water is maintained at the hot temperature until it is needed and the heating cycle restarts if the water cools or if new room-temperature water is added after the tank is drained.

When you turn on a hot water tap, hot water is drawn from the top of the tank, and new cold water is added to the bottom, where it can be most quickly heated.

Pros:

Large Volume, Large Flow – Tanked water heaters can provide a lot of hot water all at once, to multiple taps and appliances.
Low-Cost Installation – Tanked water heaters cost less initially to purchase and install compared to tankless systems.
Simple Technology – It is easy to understand, clean, and repair tanked water heaters.

Cons:

Limited Supply – It is possible to fully drain the tank and run out of hot water.
Refill/Reheat Delay – If the water heater is drained, it takes time to refill and reheat a new tank of water
Not Energy Efficient – Tanked water heaters reheat unused water all the time, which is not energy efficient.
Large Size – The tank takes up a large area in your utility space.
Maintenance – Tank water heaters build up scale and must be regularly flushed. Flushing involves draining and vinegar rinsing or scrubbing the inside and heating elements.
Thermal Expansion – You may require thermal expansion tanks to accommodate water expanding as it heats.

Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless water heaters are on-demand. They heat water as it flows through the unit using a gas burner or electric element heating a conductive pipe. Tankless water heaters can provide a potentially infinite amount of hot water while only heating when water is running through the pipe.

Pros:

Energy Efficient – Tankless water heaters only heat when the tap is running.
Unlimited Hot Water – There is no ‘running out of hot water’ because water is heated on demand.
Tidy Size – Tankless water heaters take up much less space with no need for a large tank.

Cons:

Limited Flow Rate – Tankless water can supply a limited number of gallons per minute. This means limited support for multiple taps and appliances.
Higher Installation Cost – A tankless water heater is initially more costly than a tanked water heater to purchase and install.
Complex Installation – Tankless water heaters are in-line, and therefore more complex to install into your plumbing. They may also require an upgrade to your home’s electrical system or gas line.
High Maintenance – Tankless water heaters must be constantly cleaned and maintained for optimal performance.

Factors To Consider When Choosing

Household Size and Hot Water Demand

If you have a big family or need to run multiple water appliances at once, a tanked water heater may be ideal. Smaller households with limited all-at-once hot water demand is more suitable for a tankless water heater.

However, a tankless water heater can also be installed to supply hot water to only a few selected taps, like bathrooms but not laundry.

Energy Efficiency

If your goal is energy efficiency, a tankless water heater is the superior choice. Tanked water heaters are significantly less energy efficient.

Installation Space

Tanked water heaters need a big utility space, but many homes already have this space available. Tankless water heaters fit more easily into tight spaces and can be added to a home design more easily.

Initial Budget

Tankless water heaters are more costly than tanked water heaters, so your total budget may influence your choice.

Long-Term Savings

Tanked water heaters cost more in power bills due to the constant power cycles to keep a large tank of water hot and available.

Selecting the Right Water Heater for Your Home

Determining the best water heater for your home depends on your household, lifestyle, budget, and preferences. With a larger home or budget, you can use both for different taps and purposes. Tanked water heaters are more suitable for a smaller budget and tankless water heaters are more suitable for a smaller home.

Understanding the differences can help you choose the best option for your household’s water heating needs. If you’d prefer an in-home assessment with a plumbing service professional, Aztil is here to help. Contact us today to discuss the best water heater solution for your home and lifestyle.

What Our Clients Think Of Us

Excellent

Aztil Air Conditioning

Based on 1475 reviews

Nico

Michael K. came out and did a wonderful job. There was condensation on my air filter and I was concerned about a leak. He was very thorough and made sure all avenues were checked. He also answered my questions and showed me parts on my AC. Great service!

Ana Maria Mini

Niko was great.

Cynthia Dagan

Niko was very patient and professional. Looking forward to cleaning this system.
He was great!

bernice demanche

Niko came out promptly on a Saturday and fixed my problem easily. Great customer service

Response from the owner:Bernice Demanche, I'm glad to hear that Dana provided prompt service and fixed the issue easily. Excellent customer service can really make a difference in situations like these.

Sonya S

Niko was great- very informative

Nell McLamb

Niko very nice and did a good job explaining.

HOMETOWN LANDSCAPING CO.

Niko, great service! Thank you!

Leslie Sigale

Scott McKeon

Niko was personable and knowledgeable

Alice Doyle

Antonio was great and he was personable and I really do like him the next time that I have a visit from you guys it will be from him and I almost decided not to use you guys no more because of the other two gentlemen that came they were young boys, and they did not do things properly, but Antonio was very very good and I really liked himHe was very professional so thank you very much for letting Antonio come and giving yourself a second chance have a blessed day.

Al Levy

Nicholas (I think that’s his name) was very thorough and knowledgeable. I’m going to take his recommendation for a UV light. Please send him back to install when I order it. He furthers my trust in Aztil.

Response from the owner:Thank you for your review, Al Levy. We're so glad you had a positive experience with our appliance repair services!

Betty Brousseau

Very happy with the service provided by Niko

Rick Riccardi

Technician Lazaro Powery arrived much sooner than I expected. He looked professional, and his behavior matched his appearance. I really enjoyed our brief personal chat. I always ask people I deal with if their company treats its employees well, as it matters to me. I was happy to hear that he enjoys his employment with Aztil.

His professionalism and attitude well matched his positive comments. I'm not surprised as I find Aztil to be excellent people to deal with in all requests and transactions. Lazaro sets a good example for Aztil. Thanks for sending him. When he asked, I signed another one-year service contract

Judith Vile

I had 3 terrific technicians Paul Gross who found the problem fixed it but also found a leak so I had 2 technicians Jordan and Hero come and do the duct work I was so impressed by all 3 of them their knowledge professional and the enjoyment in doing the work for their clients I give all 3 of 10 gold stars😀

Daniel Upbin

AZTIL is a real COOL company and Jackie my rep @Aztil responds ASAP when I get HOT on the phone. Seriously Jackie’s the nicest person. I don’t want to leave anyone out but Juan the technician goes above and beyond trying to solve my HVAC problems.

Brent Headberg (SummerSky 3DCAD)

Alex was very thorough and knowledgeable.

Kathy Pollett

Tino was professional and friendly. Thank you for a great service over the years.

benny pittari

I have used aztill air conditioning service for over 15 years. They have always been prompt and have always done a great job. I recently would like to praise Dana who came to my home today and his boss Jack for the great price. My wife and I feel blessed to have found them. They have been reasonable in their prices and the technician are right on point. Thank you Aztill Air. 😁😃

anna karachristos

This was my first experience with Aztil as a new homeowner. I purchased a service agreement which I thought was reasonably priced. My first scheduled maintenance was this past week by Michael King .He was extremely professional, knowledgeable and very kind in explaining everything I needed to know. He made a great suggestion in which I followed through with. He’s an asset to this very professional company. Thank you Aztil and Jonathan for a job well done!

larry nyman

Mike came by for an A/C maintenance check up. He came on time and was very friendly and professional.

Response from the owner:Hi Larry, thank you for taking the time to leave us such a positive review about Fabio. We are delighted to hear that he was on time and provided excellent service. We appreciate your feedback and are glad that you had a good experience. Thanks again!

Carole Michel

Excellent service very knowledgeable Niko send him hereafter

Marvin Kaplan

Tino was exceptional in sevicing both of my AC its. I renewed my contract with Aztil and I look forward in having Tino service me again Thanks for great service

Kath bruce

I had to have my air conditioning HVAC system replaced. I bought RHEEMS from them nine years ago or just shy of nine years ago and I had to have the whole thing replaced. It had a leak. The pressure was down 3 pounds and to pay $475 only because I had a contract with them otherwise it would’ve been 675 to check for the leak.. I decided to replace it cause I knew it was around the corner anyhow. They installed it the next day I couldn’t have been more pleased. It was effortless. It took them a while because we had some rain on and off and they couldn’t be on the roof, but they came at 9:30 and they left at 3 o’clock. I thought they did very well. They left my house clean as a button just exactly the way they found it. They were very polite and did everything that they were supposed to do in a very neat and tidy and timely manner.

Nina Kilroy

Jorge and David were the installers today. They were timely, professional, mannerly, exceptionally clean and efficient. And Sabrina in their office went beyond in responding as the cost of new units today is sticker shock!

kathy cummings

Nico is absolutely amazing! Very informative and an excellent technician! This is the second time we’ve had him and he’s great

Response from the owner:Hi Kathy, Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're glad to hear that you had an excellent experience with our service. We pride ourselves on our knowledgeable staff, and it's great to know that Ramon was able to provide you with such great service. We appreciate your feedback and hope to see you again soon!

Lisa and Scott Pullman

After 40 hours without A/C in August we were saved by Rafael. He was polite, professional and courteous. He is an asset to the company. On another note, the scheduling system used for after hours is quite poor and needs to be looked into. Thank goodness Jackie called us and attempted to remedy the situation.

jane

Naraldo Bunsie did an excellent job installing my new Trane A/C! Thanks !

juddy henry

Michael was very knowledgeable and efficient in providing service for us today. We’d love for him to come again

Larry Zauder

Your service techs and general service has improved since the corporate take over. Raphael Curci was efficient and kept us u[p to date on the progress of the installation. The person I'd like to call out as exemplary was Nico who guided us through the process and went out of his way to help us through this time. Ultimately the air handler was faulty and it took several visits to repair it. Meanwhile the handler leaked water all over the garage ceiling ruining it and causing damage to my model trains beneath. In addition the last tech broke my cable power supply which he had no business touching. I had to call Xfinity to come as an emergency for which they charged me $150.00. I will also be sending Aztil a bill for the repair of my ceiling and any damage done to my model trains.

Don Walling

Dana just finished a service call. He was very professional and explained to me what he was doing and gave me tips for the future. I have been an Aztil customer for many years and people like Dana keep me coming back.

Response from the owner:Hi Don, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Angel did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.

davidsflorida

Michael was efficient and thorough. I am very pleased with this service.

Response from the owner:Thank you

Jeffrey Welton

Juan was fantastic!

Steve Froggatt

Michael was great, he called in advance arrived on time, very professional and knowledgeable, and got the job done in a timely manner, highly recommend.

Vlad Filyakov

Michael provided excellent service on unclogging our drain line and explaining what options we have to prevent it getting clogged in the future.

Erlene Ratz

Naraldo was was a competent and efficient skilled worker..
Doesn't talk much but gets the job done quickly.

Replaced and rewired our new water heater in a very short time.

Left everything clean and Sparkling..

Would have him return anytime for the next project that might pop-up.

Response from the owner:Hi Erlene, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Rafael did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.

David Shamash

Dana Dussault, the technician that came to fix my AC and installed a new compressor was so efficient and courteous and is an asset to Aztil. I was very happy with the work.

Ilene Mack

Nico and Adrian were great. Cleaned my ac and found an oil leak. Very personable.

Response from the owner:Hi Ilene, thank you for your kind words! We're so glad to hear that Niko and Adrian did an excellent job and that you were pleased with the outcome. Thank you for being a valued customer.

shanti gilbert

Rico was friendly and very competent & efficient

Response from the owner:Hi Shanti, thank you for your kind words about Ricardo and Aztil. We are so glad to hear that you had a great experience with us. We will make sure to pass along your positive feedback to Ricardo. Thank you for choosing Aztil!

Jill Rene

Dana came on a Saturday in the pouring rain. Totally professional and knew what was wrong right away. Great job guys!

Joanne Bornstein

Dana was efficient and effective and answered all my questions. Top notch

Anthony Spinnicchia

I had a new central AC installed by Aztil today. Both of the techs, Jorge and David, were professional and friendly. I used Aztil because I have used them for service for over 10 years and have been very satisfied. I can recommend them for service and installations.